January 11, 2018
62% | |||||
18% | |||||
5% | |||||
4% | |||||
3% | |||||
2% | |||||
1% | |||||
1% | |||||
1% | |||||
0% | |||||
Total votes: 187 |
JQT 4143 votes Joined: October 2008 |
    Thursday 3:05 AM
I am tempted to investigate the Hybrid Solution of Toss (5 K) here, and do so instead of the perhaps more obvious Toss (6 9), a discard I generally don't like to make to my Own Crib.
But in the end, the PAIR of 5 Cards seems too powerful to be split up. What's important however is not to be 'lured into' retaining Keep (5 5 6 K) in the hopes of Cutting a 4 Card or 7 Card, as it is simply "reaching too far" to expect Toss (A 9) to help our Crib. |
dec 6351 votes Joined: April 2008 |
    Thursday 3:08 AM
Give up two in the crib to start to have a chance to nail sixteen. Seventeen X-5s in the deck. Not a strong eleven count for defense but probably end up playing off and/or not trip a five after a twenty for two. dec |
joekayak 1873 votes Joined: May 2016 |
    Thursday 3:45 AM
First to deal. Take the sure points. If an X card gets cut, I am almost certain to get to or beyond my first CPZ easily this hand but surely the next. No need to go for the low percentage 4 or 7 cut at this position. joekayak says: Also don't like 9-A to the crib with me already holding 5-5 and one of the 6's. I believe that results in a negative delta for that throw on this hand. |
Andy (muesli64) 2223 votes Joined: August 2009 |
    Thursday 4:04 AM
Threw 6-9. More points. I expect Ras wants to see the 5-K thrown?!! |
Rosemarie44 2052 votes Joined: March 2016 |
    Thursday 4:11 AM
Well I am in the majority. This hand has more potential for 10/12/14 points by tossing 6-9. |
glmccuskey 4094 votes Joined: April 2011 |
    Thursday 4:55 AM
I’ll go against the majority this morning. To much up side with the 5-5-6 together in your hand. It’s also a good pegger as dealer. cribbagepogo says: Give up 16 vs 12? I agree with Gary. Inushtuk1 says: Hi cp. The A-5-5-K keep has a maximum of 14, not 12. But that may not matter to you and Gary. Jazzselke says: 556K turns into 16 only if the 4 is cut. |
Jazzselke 2583 votes Joined: March 2009 |
    Thursday 4:58 AM
Not sure of the catch here by that sneaky Ras. Maybe 5K as mentioned, but I have no problem with 69 for 2 more combined points. Guest says: Am going to look like the stupid one today, but went with the theory that you can sacrifice 4 points in hand to toss a pair of 5's to you crib--held the ugly A-6-9-K. S :) Inushtuk1 says: Hi S. It’s a two part question. Both questions need a yes answer. You got the first question right. But the second one is, “Do I still have the potential for 12 points in my hand?†The answer to that question is a resounding *no*. The (5-5) toss results in a maximum hand value of 6. Do not pass GO, do not collect $200. But it’s okay. I’ve done it myself. Guest says: *Smacks forehead!* Well, duh....guess I'd better remember that second part about a 12 point hand next time. Must be all of the cold medicine I am taking lol. S:) |
james500 3916 votes Joined: June 2013 |
    Thursday 5:35 AM
Is K-5 or 5d-6d worth considering? I'll try the latter. JQT says: These were my second and third choices today ... and they've only received 2% and 1% of the votes! Inushtuk1 says: Hi gentlemen. Neither of these fit the big Hand Rule. Although (5-K) might be worthy of an exception. |
spin121 299 votes Joined: March 2016 |
Thursday 5:46 AM
Prefer to hold guaranteed 9 pts instead of only the 7 in this position. A bird in hand worth two in bush. spin121 says: A 5 5 K wasa says: I see 8 points... mistake or am I missing something? Inushtuk1 says: Hi wasa. Spin121 is referring to the guaranteed 1 Dealer peg. Guest says: Tommy two times wasa says: thanks! spin121 says: just logged on again to see what things were added since I last posted. Yes, Inushtuk1 has it right. |
BigFoot Bob 624 votes Joined: April 2016 |
    Thursday 6:48 AM
And the worm turns. Guest says: I couldn't have said that longer myself! |
Inushtuk1 1480 votes Joined: July 2016 |
    Thursday 8:17 AM
I’m sure there’s a time and a place for (5-K). But not here. I think Ras’s lesson today is exactly what JQT said. Don’t be lured by the 5-5-6-K(A-9). With 15 known points it’s def., def., def. That means avoiding the low-hanging fruit on an X-card lead. If our 5h is paired we will be sorely tempted to go for the triple, and that could be disasterous. Why tempt fate. I’m dumping my Ace on a K, Q, or J lead; and my K on a 10 lead. Inushtuk1 says: Well, a card laid is a card played. But if there *were* do-overs in cribbage, I’d pair the K lead, especially with that bright red Kd staring back at me. If my K is tripped, I recoup 2 of those points with my Ace. Let’s not play so defensively, that we wind up with a close loss; as Gougie00’s mentor likes to say. |
King Richard 2825 votes Joined: March 2009 |
    Thursday 8:33 AM
The King is not going for the head fake here. Just keep the points and get this game rolling. But, the King does want to hear from the RAS master - K-5? |
wasa 3012 votes Joined: November 2014 |
    Thursday 8:33 AM
First thought was 6-9, but because puzzle from RAS figured I'd think about 5-K or 5-5 but I just don't see it so 6-9 it is. |
Coeurdelion 5589 votes Joined: October 2007 |
    Thursday 10:52 AM
I think its between A-5-5-K (6-9), A-5-6-9 (5-K) and perhaps A-5-9-K (5-6) is worth a look:
A-5-5-K: 6pts + 5¼pts (Schell: 5.13) = 11¼pts A-5-6-9: 4pts + 6½pts (Schell: 6.66) = 10½pts A-5-9-K: 4pts + 6½pts (Schell: 6.63) = 10½pts Potential: A-5-5-K: Improves with AAA, 4444, 55, 999 + 15xXs = 27 cuts = 27/46 = 58.7% up to 10/12/14pts with 4444, 55, 999 + 15xXs = 24 cuts. A-5-6-9: Improves with AAA, 3333, 4444, 55, 666, 7777, 8888, 999 + 15xXs = 42 cuts = 42/46 = 91.3% up to 7/8/9/10pts with AAA, 4444, 55, 666, 7777, 999 = 19 cuts. A-5-9-K: Improves with AAA, 4444, 55, 666, 999 + 15xXs = 30 cuts = 30/46 = 65.2% up to 8/10pts with AAA, 55, 999, KKK = 11 cuts. Pegging: I think both A-5-6-9 and A-5-6-K will peg slightly better than A-5-5-K. Position: As First Dealer we'll be playing Defense and hoping to reach 16pts or more. Summary: Both A-5-6-9 and A-5-6-K have the same starting value but A-5-6-9 has much better potential with more cuts for improvement and more cuts for an average to good hand. A-5-5-K has many fewer cuts for improvement than A-5-6-9 and it has 24 cuts for a good hand of 10-14pts and it also starts with ¾pt more. So despite the fact that A-5-6-9 may peg slightly better I'll consolidate my position and start with a guaranteed 9pts (6pts+2pts+1pt) and throw 6-9. |
Gougie00 5723 votes Joined: March 2008 |
    Thursday 11:24 AM
The biggest bang for the buck |
HalscribCLX 5312 votes Joined: February 2008 |
    Thursday 11:30 AM
At 0*-0 playing a Defense strategy for the pegging the dynamic expected averages and Win/Loss %s are:
________________Pone's Defense___Hand__Pegs___Crib_Total____W9 %____W10 % A-5-5-K___8.52+(-1.83)+5.01=11.70____41.3____54.0 A-5-6-9___6.78+(-2.04)+6.47=11.21____41.4____53.8 A-5K-9-K__5.87+(-1.89)+6.57=10.55____37.9____51.2 5-5-6-K___9.43+(-2.11)+3.17=10.49____39.0____51.6 Defense_______L9 %____L10 % A-5-5-K_______25.6____21.1 A-5-6-9_______26.6____21.6 A-5K-9-K______25.8____23.4 5-5-6-K_______26.1____23.0 A-5-5-K is best for expected averages by 0.49pt and is very slightly best for Win %s and Loss %s both of which take account of the board position. So I'll select 6-9 to discard. After the K cut I'll play Defense to the lead. |
HalscribCLX 5312 votes Joined: February 2008 |
    Thursday 11:48 AM
If we were to adopt an Optimal or Offense strategy:
_______________Net Optimal___Hand_Pegs_Crib_Total A-5-6-9___6.78+1.67+6.47=14.92 A-5-5-K___8.52+1.13+5.01=14.67 5-5-6-K___9.43+1.33+3.17=13.93 A-5K-9-K__5.87+1.07+6.57=13.51 _______________Our Offense___Hand_Pegs_Crib_Total A-5-6-9___6.78+3.72+6.47=16.97 A-5-5-K___8.52+2.96+5.01=16.49 5-5-6-K___9.43+3.43+3.17=16.03 A-5K-9-K__5.87+1.07+2.96=15.35 I am, however, recommending a Defense strategy where Pone's pegging is minimized. |
Ras2829 5145 votes Joined: November 2008 |
    Thursday 2:36 PM
The reason for submitting this puzzle is clearly delineated by HalcribCLX above. For decades I played this hand or similar as A-5-5-X with 6-9 discard and believed that was correct most any place on the board. Queries on Halscrib, REX, and Cribbage Prof showed that 5-X was often the correct choice. Since first hand of game, dealer choice should be defense; so the majority have it just right. How would it have been if the hand had been A-5-5-6-9-J? Ras2829 says: Based on my scant empirical data the 5-J average is 7.088 (1,676) 3/91 while 5-K weighs in at 6.726 (1,742) 5/91. The difference in those averages favors the 5-J discard whether playing defense, optimal, or offense. How can I ever live long enough to learn this game? Coeurdelion says: The main reason 5-J is better than 5-K is the approximately ¼pt for the 1pt for his nob. With a difference of 0.362pt that leaves about 0.1pt advantage to 5-J, presumably as its a key connector. But perhaps this means that A-5-5-J would still be the better choice playing Defense? |
Ras2829 5145 votes Joined: November 2008 |
    Thursday 2:38 PM
A picture is worth a 1,000 words!! JQT says: "If a picture is worth a thousand words, please paint me the Gettysburg Address." -Leo Rosten. He also wrote, "Truth is stranger than fiction; fiction has to make sense." I like that one! Finally, Leo also said, "The writer wants to be understood much more than he wants to be respected or praised or even loved. And that, perhaps, is what makes him different from others." -Leo Rosten Ras2829 says: Hi JQT - That response by Leo Rosten was masterful and thanks for sharing. Hope many will read the "Gettysburg Address" in memory of the genius who composed it. That would be a great way to remember the amazing talent of Abraham Lincoln. Tell "Honest Abe" happy birthday on February 12. |