June 5, 2025

*** This hand was suggested by Jason19
55*-60  ?
56%
56%
20%
20%
15%
15%
5%
5%
2%
2%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Total votes: 314
Jason19I went with the flush. Crib netted only 6, so maybe not a great toss.
Rosemarie44

Joined: March 2016 (2215 votes)

Thursday 3:06 AM
tevdodd

Joined: May 2021 (238 votes)

Thursday 3:20 AM
Sneaky good submission today. Normally I keep the flush from this arrangement, or toss 5-7 if there is no flush. HOWEVER, we're -15 at this point, it's time to swing for the fences. Keeping 55JQ gives us 15 cuts to 16+. That moves us to 71 before we count the crib. (Which now may be empty, but thems the breaks when you've got this many big hand cuts). 4 cut is rough for us today, but again, thems the breaks. Play offense, hopefully over over the next 6 deals you can be +2.5 of average on each, or at least +1.5 of each to give yourself a chance to peg out on the last.
glmccuskey says: Defense is the play today. We are sure to get well past 71 for our next deal. Need to stop our opponent from getting to 71.
tevdodd

Joined: May 2021 (238 votes)

Thursday 3:21 AM
Wordle 1,447 6/6

🟩⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟩⬜🟨🟨⬜
🟩🟩⬜🟨⬜
⬜🟨⬜⬜⬜
⬜⬜🟨⬜⬜
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩

Don't even want to claim this as a win this morning, I botched my 3rd guess, took it off hard mode for guess 4 and 5, and created like 15 new words.
JQT

Joined: October 2008 (4489 votes)

Thursday 3:42 AM
Discarding when we are the Dealer is often a more challenging task than discarding while we are Pone, and today's puzzle illustrates this well. 🎨 🧩 🍹

When we are Pone, we retain the good stuff, get rid of the bad stuff, and that's it! But as the Dealer, we're looking to "build" the best combination of Pegging, Hand, and Crib, and it's often a bit trickier to find the most productive way to "balance" our resources. 😐

If we retain the FLUSH, we start with Seven Points in our Hand (which is incidentally not a great Pegging Hand), and yet we stash a Crib Value of nearly Nine Points into our own Box!Β πŸ’°

However, if we hold (5 5 J Q) or (5 5 Q K), we begin with a better Pegging Hand and Ten Points, with either Toss (7 K) or (7 J) barely eking out a Crib Value of about Three or Three-and-a-Half Points. β˜”

But unless we can peg Three or Four Holes MORE with this Hand (something that I tend to strongly doubt), it's probably better to retain the FLUSH and jettison the PAIR of 5 Cards.Β πŸͺ‚

It's probably even better to Toss (5 7) than Toss (7 K) or Toss (7 J), but if we hold the FLUSH, we can avoid having to invest any time or energy into doing all of that secondary decision-making work of having to choose between these three likely inferior ideas. 🍑

Let's Toss (5 5) today, and seek the greatest combined total. After the 4 of Diamonds Cut Card, we still have Seven Points in our Hand, but we could have up to Twenty-Four Points in our Crib, that is, if Pone decided to Toss (4 6) or (6 6)! 😏

Malcolm Nance on Times Radio FRONTLINE πŸ’  πŸ”± 🌻
"Asymmetric Warfare in Ukraine" πŸ”΅ 🟑
https://youtu.be/W9q9YIBo8eE

Wordle 1,447 5/6 (what we do before we marry them)

β¬›πŸŸ¨πŸŸ¨β¬›β¬›
β¬›πŸŸ©β¬›β¬›πŸŸ¨
β¬›πŸŸ©πŸŸ©β¬›β¬›
β¬›πŸŸ©πŸŸ©β¬›β¬›
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
dec

Joined: April 2008 (6831 votes)

Thursday 3:55 AM
In my scenario they discard X-6. 5-5 when your hand can still has a chance for a dozen. dec
mrob2199

Joined: February 2009 (1676 votes)

Thursday 4:00 AM
A picture cut may yield us a 12 hand 10 crib-looking for the same cards no matter how we break it up
mfetchCT425

Joined: February 2009 (1613 votes)

Thursday 4:21 AM
Nickels to the crib.
usacoder

Joined: August 2019 (1063 votes)

Thursday 4:24 AM
On and off over the past several years I have been working on a Cribbage scoring system. Today I may give up. I went over to ChatGPT to give me the discard. It gave me similar results to my program but with a heck of lot more information. Here's a link to my ChatGPT session. https://chatgpt.com/share/68417dee-19a8-8001-9858-5d4f6d36bbd2
JQT says: Calculating the Expected Averages of both Hand and Crib as well as Probabilistic Outcomes are the computer's strengths, but where humans might still have an edge would be in the understanding of both the PEGGING as well as the POSITIONAL considerations, so I would recommend not giving up but steering your effort into those latter areas. I have also dedicated a significant amount of effort into many aspects of Cribbage, but with the loss of the Halscrib source code, it's easy to become discouraged, but Cribbage, 'This Game of Ours,' is still very fertile ground for ideas and development. All one need do is look at the explosion of recent, renewed interest in a game like Chess, with at times MILLIONS of new accounts being created every month during the pandemic, to see the similar possibilities for a game such as Cribbage. More books about Chess are published every week than exist in the entirety of Cribbage, and while 'Our Game' may never be even 1% as popular, even that level would entail a quadrupling of interest each and every calendar year! Let's try to not become discouraged, for while our own perceptions may wax and wane as we become older and as time marches on, if we stand back and observe carefully, there are hopeful signs as we witness the developing interest of many new and younger players. πŸ€ - j q t -
glmccuskey

Joined: April 2011 (4472 votes)

Thursday 4:25 AM
Gougie00

Joined: March 2008 (6145 votes)

Thursday 4:40 AM
Another Al Miller axiom was to "never be seduced by the flush". What would you do if there wasnt a flush? I kept the pat 9 point hand. With the 4 cut there is no guarantee the crib is going to have any more that 2 points. I want to be at hold 70 so I need to peg a little.

After a month of rain here in Northern Massachusetts, here comes the Sun and 95 degrees. That was abrupt.
JQT says: Lots of interesting perspectives today! We often lean toward the FLUSH as being "Hard to Read" during the pegging, and thus a DEFENSIVE option, yet there are all kinds of FLUSHES, and those with a RUN in them (especially a RUN of X Cards!) are likely to be poor peggers. Defensively therefore, Rex Cribbage AGREES with your choice today, so it may be a matter of just HOW DEFENSIVE as opposed to HOW OFFENSIVE a posture we wish to adopt here.
domandcarol

Joined: August 2023 (131 votes)

Thursday 4:45 AM
Just taking a shot a big crib
MarktheShark

Joined: January 2024 (478 votes)

Thursday 4:58 AM
Toughie. Without the flush option, 5-7 is clearly the pitch. However, I am far behind positionally, so I need to hope for a good cut and to be able to defend.
Jazzselke

Joined: March 2009 (2851 votes)

Thursday 5:19 AM
Sgt Pegger

Joined: July 2017 (660 votes)

Thursday 5:21 AM
IMO, this makes the most sense overall.
Djgoat

Joined: December 2023 (259 votes)

Thursday 5:35 AM
Keeping the pat 7 and hoping for a big hit in the crib
james500

Joined: June 2013 (4321 votes)

Thursday 5:53 AM
Hopefully they discarded K6.

Wordle 1,447 4/6

πŸŸ¨β¬›πŸŸ¨β¬›β¬›
β¬›πŸŸ©β¬›β¬›πŸŸ¨
β¬›πŸŸ©πŸŸ¨πŸŸ©πŸŸ¨
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
Unusual to see this word in the singular.
Eolus619

Joined: June 2020 (1734 votes)

Thursday 6:44 AM
Thanks to all..so far..for the varied perspectives on board position strategy and discard. This is the classic example of Ras’s Big Hand Rule which he says applies 95% of the time. As dealer, 5-5 can be tossed if the keep can cut to 12. However, for the remaining 5%, Jazz’s increasingly famous cribbage theorem can apply…”?? is the best answer until it isn’t β€œ Today..for me, in Ras I trust.
Eolus619 says: I trust in you too Jazz..just not applying your theorem todayπŸ‘
Andy (muesli64)

Joined: August 2009 (2337 votes)

Thursday 10:43 AM
Best offence needed.
HalscribCLX

Joined: February 2008 (5680 votes)

Thursday 1:05 PM
At 55*-60 playing a Defense strategy for the pegging the dynamic expected averages and Win/Loss %s are:

________________Pone's
Defense___Hand__Pegs____Crib_Total____W4 %____W5 %
5-J-Q-K____11.17+(-2.09)+5.93=15.01____11.0____32.5
7-J-Q-K_____9.02+(-2.39)+8.27=14.90____11.8____34.6

Defense_______L4 %____L5 %
5-J-Q-K________14.5____42.8
7-J-Q-K________13.6____41.0

5-J-Q-K is better for expected averages by 0.11pt. bit 7-J-Q-K is slightly better for Win %s and lower for Loss %s. So, I'll select 5-5 to discard.

After the 4 cut I'll play Defense to the lead.
jmath714

Joined: January 2012 (1318 votes)

Thursday 1:10 PM
Gotta be careful with my words, make sure I’m not representing anyone other than myself here πŸ˜‚
Assman

Joined: May 2024 (413 votes)

Thursday 4:57 PM
Excellent puzzle. I went this way because I underestimated the difference between 55 in dealers’s crib and 57 in dealers crib. Turns out the difference is about three points. So in that case, it’s better to hold the seven instead of the nine and hope that you make it up in the crib. I will say that, although I’m inexperienced compared to most every commenter, I’ve rarely seen 55 explode in the crib. Obviously it will when a quartet of X cards appear in the crib, which certainly occurs every now and then. But I’ve seen seen 55 disappoint with six or eight points or something like that (not that six or eight in the crib is a bad thing).

πŸ€·πŸΌβ€β™‚οΈ